New — The State of AI Hiring 2026. Every number sourced→
Ethics & Compliance

AI Hiring Lawsuits Tracker: Active Cases, Status and Employer Takeaways

A maintained tracker of AI hiring lawsuits: court, status, legal theory and employer takeaway for each case. Updated monthly with docket sources.

AI hiring lawsuits: allegation or ruling? A card shows how the tracker words claims alleges, rulings the court held, allowed, granted and consent decrees agreed terms, not a finding.

TL;DR: AI hiring lawsuits are legal claims that an automated screening tool discriminated against applicants or breached a statute governing applicant data. This tracker lists seven matters, each with its court, status as of a stated date, legal theory and employer takeaway. Entries describe allegations and rulings separately; an allegation is not a finding.

Updated 28 October 2026; docket status as read on 28 October 2026. Recorded the Harper v. Sirius XM judgment and notice of appeal, the Mobley v. Workday class-certification motion, and the 24 September 2026 filing in Kistler v. Eightfold AI; added Baker v. CVS Health and Swanson v. IBM.

Disclaimer: This tracker is not legal advice and makes no prediction about the outcome of any case.

Key takeaways

  • The court in Mobley v. Workday preliminarily certified an Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA) collective on 16 May 2025, in the Northern District of California. According to the CourtListener docket, the plaintiffs filed a motion to certify a class on 14 September 2026, with a hearing set for 9 March 2027.
  • Kistler v. Eightfold AI raises a consumer-reporting theory under the Fair Credit Reporting Act and California statutes. The court vacated the hearing on the motion to dismiss, and no ruling has been found as of the as-of date (PacerMonitor).
  • In Harper v. Sirius XM, the CourtListener docket shows the court granted Sirius XM's motion for judgment on 30 September 2026, and the plaintiff filed a notice of appeal to the Sixth Circuit on 27 October 2026. Trade press described the ruling in different terms (HR Dive); this page uses the docket wording.
  • EEOC v. iTutorGroup ended in a consent decree announced on 11 September 2023 with a $365,000 payment, based on the EEOC's allegation that software automatically rejected older applicants (EEOC).
  • A loss or settlement in one case does not set the outcome of another. Each row records only what the docket or a primary source states.

This tracker covers claims over hiring tools, against employers and vendors, and what each court or agency has done so far. Every row below ends in an employer control. For how screening and interview tools are built, see evidence-based AI interviews.

Which AI hiring lawsuits are active in 2026?

AI hiring lawsuits are legal claims that an automated screening or interview tool discriminated against applicants or breached a statute governing applicant data, such as a consumer-reporting law or a state lie-detector statute. The table lists seven matters.

CaseCourtStatus (date shown in each row)Legal theoryEmployer takeawaySource
Mobley v. Workday, 3:23-cv-00770-RFLN.D. Cal. (Judge Rita F. Lin)ADEA collective preliminarily certified 16 May 2025. Fourth Amended Complaint filed 10 Jul 2026. Motion to certify a class filed 14 Sep 2026; opposition/response filed 10 Nov 2026 (Dkt 449); plaintiffs' reply due 8 Dec 2026; hearing 9 Mar 2027 (CourtListener docket, read 11 Nov 2026). Detail on the case page.Disparate impact (Title VII, ADEA, ADA). Vendor as the employers' "agent": the court's order of 12 Jul 2024 allowed that claim to proceed.A vendor and an employer may both be in the frame. Know which AI features are on, and keep bias-testing and decision records.CourtListener docket; AI Lawsuit Tracker. Last verified 28 Oct 2026.
Kistler v. Eightfold AI, 3:26-cv-01768N.D. Cal. (Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers)Removed to federal court 2 Mar 2026. Motion to dismiss pending; the court vacated the 24 Jul 2026 hearing. The docket showed no ruling as of 13 Oct 2026. Detail on the case page.Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), California Investigative Consumer Reporting Agencies Act (ICRAA) and Unfair Competition Law (UCL). Plaintiffs allege that match scores and profiles are "consumer reports" and that Eightfold is a "consumer reporting agency". Eightfold's position, per its April 2026 motion: it is not a consumer reporting agency and its output is not a consumer report.Check whether any AI tool ingests third-party data. Map the FCRA disclosure and adverse-action workflow. Get the vendor's FCRA position in writing.CourtListener docket; PacerMonitor. Last verified 28 Oct 2026.
Harper v. Sirius XM Radio, 2:25-cv-12403E.D. Mich. (Judge Terrence G. Berg)Complaint filed 4 Aug 2025. The docket shows the court granted Sirius XM's motion for judgment on 30 Sep 2026 and entered judgment the same day. Plaintiff filed a notice of appeal to the Sixth Circuit on 27 Oct 2026.Title VII and 42 U.S.C. §1981 (race), disparate treatment and disparate impact. Plaintiff alleges iCIMS scoring and rejection from all of about 150 applications. HR Dive reported the court's reasoning as: no direct or circumstantial evidence of discriminatory intent, and disparate impact not shown.Plaintiffs need evidence. The outcome was fact-specific, is under appeal, and is not a safe harbor.CourtListener docket; HR Dive (5 Oct 2026, updated 6 Oct). Last verified 28 Oct 2026.
EEOC v. iTutorGroup, 1:22-cv-02565E.D.N.Y.Consent decree announced 11 Sep 2023: $365,000, EEOC monitoring for at least five years, training, policy changes, and no requests for birth dates. The EEOC alleged that the software automatically rejected women aged 55 and over and men aged 60 and over (200+ applicants).ADEA (age); alleged intentional programming.Configuration is the risk. Review knock-out rules and age-proxy fields.EEOC. Last verified 15 Oct 2026.
ACLU of Colorado charge v. Intuit and HireVueColorado Civil Rights Division and EEOC (administrative; not in court)Charge filed 19 Mar 2025. No public outcome found. Both companies publicly deny the allegations: HireVue says Intuit did not use a HireVue AI-based assessment, and Intuit says the allegations are "without merit".ADA, Title VII and the Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act. Alleged: accommodation and speech-recognition performance.Offer a human-captioned or alternative interview path, and log accommodations.HR Dive (24 Mar 2025). Last verified 15 Oct 2026.
Baker v. CVS Health (video interview)D. Mass. (Judge Patti B. Saris)As reported on 23 Feb 2024, the court denied dismissal of the notice claim. Defendants are CVS Health Corporation and CVS Pharmacy, Inc.; HireVue is named only as the technology CVS allegedly used, not as a defendant. Bloomberg Law reported that the applicant agreed to settle in Jul 2024, with terms undisclosed.Massachusetts lie-detector statute (applicants must get notice). The plaintiff alleged the video interview technology analysed facial expressions, eye contact and voice intonation.State-specific notice rules apply to video analysis.New England Business Law Update (23 Feb 2024); Bloomberg Law. Last verified 28 Oct 2026.
Swanson v. IBMW.D. Tex.HR Examiner reported that the case was filed on 23 May 2026. As of 15 Oct 2026 we have not read the complaint or found a ruling. The plaintiff alleges that the auto-rejection of a rehire application "appeared to be generated by AI screening"; the case is mostly about age discrimination and layoffs, and AI is one allegation.ADEA.Rehire and boomerang pools are also screened.HR Examiner (secondary source). Last verified 15 Oct 2026.

Reading notes. Entries use "alleges" and "alleged" for claims and "the court held", "allowed" or "granted" for rulings. A row's status changes only when a docket, an EEOC release or a named law-firm alert says so. Two matters have their own pages: Mobley v. Workday and Kistler v. Eightfold AI.

What changed this month?

DateCaseChange
27 Oct 2026Harper v. Sirius XMPlaintiff filed a notice of appeal to the Sixth Circuit
30 Sep 2026Harper v. Sirius XMCourt granted Sirius XM's motion for judgment (docket wording)
24 Sep 2026Kistler v. Eightfold AIDefendant filed a "Statement of Recent Decision"
14 Sep 2026Mobley v. WorkdayPlaintiffs filed the motion to certify a class (hearing 9 Mar 2027)

Last swept: 28 October 2026 for the CourtListener dockets; 15 October 2026 for the other rows.

How this tracker is maintained

The tracker is swept on the first Monday of each month. Every row carries an as-of date and a source. We cite dockets, EEOC releases, named law-firm alerts and trade-press reports for status, not vendor blogs. Entries that rest on a secondary source are marked, and are replaced when the primary document has been read.

Each cell below is a question to put to your own process or your vendor. None of them is a conclusion about any case.

Table matching five legal theories disparate impact, disparate treatment, FCRA and ICRAA, state lie-detector statute, ADA accommodation to the cases where they appear and a control question for employ

Legal theoryWhere it appears in the tableControl question
Disparate impact (Title VII, ADEA, ADA)Mobley v. Workday; Harper v. Sirius XM (as pleaded)Is the tool's output tested for selection rates by group, as the bias audit definition describes, and are decision records kept?
Disparate treatment, including intentional configurationEEOC v. iTutorGroupHave knock-out rules and age-proxy fields been reviewed, and who can change them?
FCRA and ICRAA (consumer reporting)Kistler v. Eightfold AIDoes any tool ingest third-party data? What is the vendor's written position on consumer-reporting status? Is the adverse-action workflow mapped?
State lie-detector statuteBaker v. CVS HealthWhere video analysis is used in a state with such a statute, is notice given to applicants?
ADA accommodationACLU charge v. Intuit and HireVueIs there an alternative interview path, and are accommodations logged?

How do you read a case status?

Case status is procedural language, and each term means something narrower than it sounds.

  • Motion to dismiss. A request that the court end a claim at the pleading stage, treating the plaintiffs' allegations as true for that purpose. A denial means the case continues. It does not mean the claim is proven.
  • Summary judgment. A request that the court decide a claim without a trial because the facts are not genuinely disputed. A grant ends the claim on the record before the court.
  • Conditional or preliminary certification. In an ADEA collective action, an early step that lets plaintiffs notify similarly situated people who may choose to join. It is not a finding of liability.
  • Rule 23 class certification. The court's decision on whether claims can proceed for a defined class. It is separate from the merits.
  • Opt-in period. The window in which eligible people choose to join a collective action.
  • Consent decree. A settlement entered as a court order. It records agreed terms. It is not a finding that the allegations are true.
  • Taken under submission, or submitted on the papers. The court will decide the motion without oral argument.

The Harper outcome was fact-specific and is not a safe harbor for other tools or employers. A consent decree is not a finding. An individual settlement, such as the one Bloomberg Law reported in Baker, sets no rule.

Which cases are documented in more detail?

Mobley v. Workday turns on the "agent" ruling in the table, which concerns who can be sued, not whether anyone is liable. The plaintiffs filed their Rule 23 motion to certify a class on 14 September 2026, and the hearing is set for 9 March 2027, according to the docket.

Kistler v. Eightfold AI turns on the consumer-report theory set out in the table; the plaintiffs' allegation and Eightfold's denial are both there. As of 13 Oct 2026, the docket showed no ruling on the motion to dismiss.

Statutes next to the cases

Rules are not cases, and they are listed separately for that reason.

  • Colorado SB 26-189: Akin Gump reports that it was signed on 14 May 2026, repeals and reenacts the Colorado AI Act (SB 24-205), and applies from 1 January 2027 (Akin Gump, 6 Oct 2026). A public rulemaking hearing on the Attorney General's draft rules was scheduled for 26 October 2026.
  • New York City Local Law 144: the city's Department of Consumer and Worker Protection describes a bias audit within one year before use of an automated employment decision tool and candidate notice 10 business days before use; enforcement began on 5 July 2023 (NYC DCWP).
  • California and Illinois: the California Civil Rights Council regulations on automated-decision systems and Illinois HB 3773 are covered in the state-law tracker.

The compliance detail for each is in the tracker of state AI hiring laws.

What do documented cases of AI hiring bias look like in practice?

The tracker records legal claims. Documented examples of bias in hiring tools, including discontinued tools and research findings, are collected on a separate page of documented AI hiring bias examples. They are not repeated here.

What controls should any hiring-AI vendor be able to show?

The matrix above points to five things a buyer can ask any vendor to demonstrate:

  • A human decision point on advance and reject, and whether it is configurable.
  • An audit trail of what the system did and when.
  • An explanation of each recommendation, attached to the candidate's record.
  • Records export, so the employer can produce them on request.
  • Written answers on data sources and consumer-reporting status.

FAQ

Who has been sued over AI hiring?

The vendors and employers named in the table: Workday, Eightfold AI, Sirius XM, iTutorGroup, CVS Health and IBM, and, in an administrative charge, Intuit and HireVue. Each row states the claim as an allegation.

Is it illegal to use AI to screen resumes?

The cases on this page concern discrimination, applicant data and notice, not the use of AI to screen resumes as such. Whether a given law restricts a given tool depends on the statute and the facts. This is not legal advice.

Can an employer be sued for AI hiring bias?

Yes. Employers are defendants in several of the matters listed, including Sirius XM, CVS Health and IBM. Mobley v. Workday also concerns whether a vendor can be reached as the employers' agent; see the next question.

Can a vendor be sued for AI hiring bias?

In Mobley, the court allowed the agent claim against Workday to proceed. That is not a finding of liability. Eightfold AI is also a defendant in Kistler, on a consumer-reporting theory.

Is there a HireVue lawsuit?

An administrative charge against Intuit and HireVue was filed in March 2025. It is not a court case, no public outcome has been found, and both companies deny the allegations (HR Dive, 24 March 2025).

Has the EEOC brought an AI hiring case?

EEOC v. iTutorGroup ended in a consent decree announced on 11 September 2023, with a $365,000 payment (EEOC). The EEOC alleged that the software automatically rejected older applicants.

How often is this tracker updated?

Monthly, on the first Monday. Each row shows the date its status was last verified.

See what a decision record looks like

Every control above depends on records. See an evidence pack in a demo to see what a decision record with reasoning and a transcript looks like.

ComplianceAI hiring law
Was this useful?

Comments

No comments yet.

Comments are closed on this post.