TL;DR: NYC Local Law 144 makes it unlawful to use an automated employment decision tool to screen candidates or employees for New York City jobs unless a bias audit was done within the past year and a summary is public. Employers must also notify candidates at least 10 business days before use. The employer or employment agency carries the duty, not the vendor. The law requires no specific action based on audit results. Penalties are set per violation under Admin. Code § 20-872.
General information, not legal advice. Have counsel confirm how this applies to you.
Local Law 144 requires three things:
- Bias audit by an independent auditor, within one year before use.
- Public summary of the results, posted on the employment section of the website.
- Notice to candidates at least 10 business days before use.
Updated 28 October 2026.
Key takeaways
- Local Law 144 requires three things before an employer uses an automated employment decision tool to screen candidates in New York City: a bias audit within one year, a public summary, and notice to candidates at least 10 business days earlier (NYC Council, Local Law 144 of 2021).
- The duty sits with the employer or employment agency. A vendor may commission an audit, but the DCWP FAQ states the vendor is not responsible for one (DCWP FAQ, 29 June 2023).
- The law requires no specific action based on the audit results (DCWP FAQ II.2).
- Penalties under § 20-872 are tiered: not more than $500 for a first violation, and $500 to $1,500 for each subsequent one. Each day of non-compliant use and each missing notice is a separate violation (Legistar text).
- Enforcement began on 5 July 2023 (DCWP FAQ). The New York State Comptroller published an audit of the city's enforcement on 2 December 2025 (OSC). It found that DCWP identified a single non-compliance issue across 32 companies, while the auditors found at least 17 potential instances among the same companies.
If your hiring uses software that scores, ranks or screens candidates for New York City jobs, Local Law 144 may require an audit, a public summary and advance notice. Penalties accrue per violation, and each day of non-compliant use counts as a separate one. This page sets out what the statute and the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP) rules require, who carries each duty, and how the law has been enforced since July 2023.
New York City's rule is one of several in force, and the others sit in the tracker of state AI employment laws. This page covers the city rule only.
What does Local Law 144 require?
The law is codified at NYC Admin. Code §§ 20-870 to 20-874. It makes it unlawful to use an automated employment decision tool to screen a candidate or employee for an employment decision unless two conditions are met (Legistar text of Local Law 144 of 2021):
- A bias audit was done within one year before use of the tool.
- A summary of the audit is publicly available.
In addition, § 20-871(b) separately requires notice to candidates at least 10 business days before use.
DCWP adopted the implementing rules, 6 RCNY §§ 5-300 to 5-304, in April 2023. It did so after two proposals, on 23 September 2022 and 23 December 2022, and after hearings on 4 November 2022 and 23 January 2023 (DCWP Notice of Adoption, April 2023).
The audit. The tool must have been subject to a bias audit within the year before it is used. The rules define what the audit must contain and who may perform it, both covered below.
The summary. The employer must make a summary of the audit publicly available (6 RCNY § 5-303).
The notice. Candidates must receive notice at least 10 business days before the tool is used (Admin. Code § 20-871(b)).
DCWP states: "The Law does not require any specific actions based on the results of a bias audit" (DCWP FAQ II.2, 29 June 2023). The audit is a condition of use, not a pass-or-fail test.
Whether the law reaches a particular tool depends on its scope test, which is the next section.
Does Local Law 144 apply to your hiring?
A tool is within the law when it meets three conditions. It uses machine learning, statistical modeling, data analytics or artificial intelligence. It helps make employment decisions. And it "substantially assists or replaces discretionary decision-making" (DCWP FAQ I.2 to I.6). The law covers only candidates who applied for a specific position, or employees being considered for promotion, so resume-bank scans and outreach fall outside it (DCWP FAQ I.2 to I.6).
The job must also be "in the city". Under the DCWP FAQ, that means any of three things: an office in New York City at least part time; a fully remote job with a New York City office associated with it; or the employment agency using the tool is located in New York City (DCWP FAQ I.2 to I.6).
The three questions below put the test in order.
| Question | If yes | If no |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Is the job in the city? (NYC office at least part time; fully remote with an associated NYC office; or an agency located in NYC) | Go to question 2 | Outside the FAQ's "in the city" test; counsel decides edge cases |
| 2. Does the tool use machine learning, statistical modeling, data analytics or AI, help make employment decisions, and substantially assist or replace discretionary decision-making? | Go to question 3 | Outside the scope test |
| 3. Did the person apply for a specific position? | The three conditions apply | Outside the law (resume-bank scans and outreach) |
Two tool types raise the scope question directly: scored AI interviews and resume rankers. The page on AI interview software explains how the first kind works. Whether a particular scored AI interview falls inside "substantially assist or replace discretionary decision-making" is a legal question for counsel, and this page does not resolve it.
For a tool within scope, the next question is what the audit must contain.
What must a bias audit contain?
What a bias audit is has its own page. The rules set a minimum: the selection rate or scoring rate and the impact ratio for sex, race/ethnicity and intersectional categories, plus the count of individuals in the "unknown" category. A category that makes up less than 2% of the data may be excluded from the impact-ratio calculations; the summary must give the auditor's justification plus the excluded category's applicant count and selection or scoring rate (6 RCNY § 5-301(b) to (d)).
The rule prescribes the arithmetic, and the law requires no specific action based on the results (DCWP FAQ II.2). The impact ratio formula page covers the calculation. The process page, how to run the audit, covers data rules and a dated cost range.
Who can perform the audit, and who is responsible for it?
The rules require an independent auditor. An auditor is not independent if it is or was involved in using, developing or distributing the tool, has an employment relationship with the employer or the vendor during the audit, or has a direct or material indirect financial interest in either (6 RCNY § 5-300; DCWP FAQ IV.1 to IV.2). DCWP keeps no approved-auditor list.
Employers and employment agencies are responsible for the audit. The vendor that created the tool "is not responsible for a bias audit of the tool", though a vendor may commission one (DCWP FAQ V.1 to V.2).
One data point on cost: Bias Audit USA publishes a list price of $5,500 for the first tool (Bias Audit USA pricing, fetched 15 October 2026). That is one provider's published price and not a market figure. Penalties under the statute, by contrast, accrue per violation, as the penalties section below sets out.
What must be published, and when must candidates be notified?
Publication. The employer must post the summary and its distribution date on the employment section of its website, and a clearly labelled link is allowed. The summary must stay posted for at least six months after the latest use of the tool (6 RCNY § 5-303).
Notice. The employer must give notice to candidates and employees who reside in New York City at least 10 business days before use, with instructions to request a reasonable accommodation (DCWP FAQ VI). The notice must also include instructions for requesting an alternative selection process "if available", and if the data type, source and retention policy are not already on the website, the employer must provide them within 30 days of a written request (Admin. Code § 20-871(b)).
What a finished summary looks like
Pfizer published its "Bias Audit Summary of the HiredScore Grade System" on 29 May 2026. The data period runs from August 2022 to February 2025, groups under 2% are excluded, and the summary shows three impact-ratio definitions (Pfizer summary).
The checklist below sets out what a summary must contain, under 6 RCNY § 5-303 and, for excluded categories, § 5-301.
| Element | What the summary shows | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Audit date | When the bias audit was conducted | 6 RCNY § 5-303(a)(1) |
| Distribution date | When the summary was first made available | 6 RCNY § 5-303(a)(2) |
| Data source and explanation | Where the data came from and how it was used | 6 RCNY § 5-303(a)(1) |
| Unknown-category count | The number of individuals whose category is unknown | 6 RCNY § 5-303(a)(1) |
| Number of applicants | The count of applicants in the data | 6 RCNY § 5-303(a)(1) |
| Rates and impact ratios | Selection or scoring rates and impact ratios for all categories | 6 RCNY § 5-303(a)(1) |
| Excluded categories | The justification and the counts for any category under 2% | 6 RCNY § 5-301 |
What are the penalties under Local Law 144?
The statute sets the penalty. Admin. Code § 20-872(a) provides for a civil penalty "not more than $500 for a first violation and each additional violation occurring on the same day as the first violation, and not less than $500 nor more than $1,500 for each subsequent violation" (Legistar text).
| Violation | Penalty under § 20-872(a) |
|---|---|
| First violation, and each additional violation on the same day | Not more than $500 |
| Each subsequent violation | Not less than $500 nor more than $1,500 |
Under § 20-872(b), each day of non-compliant use is a separate violation. Under § 20-872(c), each failure to give a required notice is a separate violation.
Some summaries state the range as "$500 to $1,500 per day". That is not what § 20-872 says.
DCWP refers discrimination claims to the New York City Commission on Human Rights (DCWP FAQ VII). Anti-discrimination law applies regardless of audit results: the DCWP FAQ says federal, state and city laws prohibit discrimination, and the law requires no specific action based on audit results. The documented AI hiring bias cases show how discrimination claims have been framed.
How is Local Law 144 enforced?
DCWP enforces the law. Complaints go to 311 or to the DCWP website, and enforcement began on 5 July 2023 (DCWP FAQ, 29 June 2023; DCWP page on automated employment decision tools).
The Comptroller's audit
The Office of the New York State Comptroller published "Enforcement of Local Law 144 – Automated Employment Decision Tools" on 2 December 2025. It covers July 2023 to June 2025 (OSC). The report assesses how DCWP has enforced the law over that period. According to the Comptroller, "DCWP surveyed websites and bias audits of 32 companies and identified just a single issue of non-compliance," while the auditors reviewed the same companies and "identified at least 17 instances of potential non-compliance under LL144." The audit also states that DCWP received only two AEDT complaints during the audit's scope and did not investigate whether its complaint intake process worked. The Comptroller recommended that DCWP route AEDT complaints received by 311 to DCWP (OSC).
The 2023 compliance baseline
A study by Wright and co-authors, presented at FAccT in June 2024, had 155 student investigators check 391 employers. Eighteen had posted audit reports and 13 had posted transparency notices (arXiv 2406.01399). The authors call this "null compliance", because employers decide whether the law applies to them. The study records the position in 2023 and is dated accordingly.
What changed since 2023
| Date | Event | Source |
|---|---|---|
| December 2021 | Local Law 144 enacted | Legistar |
| 1 January 2023 | Law takes effect | Legistar |
| April 2023 | Final rules | DCWP Notice of Adoption |
| 5 July 2023 | Enforcement begins | DCWP FAQ |
| 2 December 2025 | Comptroller audit published | OSC |
Administrative enforcement is one route, and private litigation is another. The tracker of AI hiring litigation covers court cases.
How does Local Law 144 fit with federal, state and EU rules?
Executive Order 14281 (23 April 2025), Sec. 4, directs agencies to "deprioritize enforcement" of disparate-impact liability (White House). It does not change the text of Title VII. The EEOC's May 2023 AI technical-assistance page returned a not-found error on 22 October 2026. Warden AI reports its removal (Warden AI), and no EEOC announcement was found.
Other jurisdictions have their own rules, each covered on its own page. Colorado's separate statute is covered under Colorado's AI Act duties. California's is covered under California's automated-decision rules. Illinois's is covered under Illinois's AI employment provisions. The EU AI Act high-risk rules apply to hiring AI used in the EU.
A federal case offers a different legal route from Local Law 144. Mobley v. Workday alleges age discrimination through a screening vendor, as Holland & Knight reported in May 2025. The allegations are not findings. As of 19 October 2026, the CourtListener docket showed a Fourth Amended Complaint filed on 10 July 2026 and a motion to certify a class filed on 14 September 2026.
FAQ
Does Local Law 144 apply to remote jobs?
Yes, where the job is associated with a New York City office or the employment agency using the tool is located in New York City. Fully remote roles with no New York City office association, used by an employer or by an agency located outside New York City, fall outside the DCWP FAQ's "in the city" test (DCWP FAQ I.2 to I.6). Counsel decides edge cases.
Is there a passing score for a Local Law 144 bias audit?
No. The law does not require any specific action based on the results of an audit (DCWP FAQ II.2). The 0.80 figure is not a Local Law 144 test, and impact ratio and the four-fifths rule explains the reference.
Who enforces Local Law 144?
DCWP enforces it. Complaints go to 311 or the DCWP website, and DCWP refers discrimination claims to the Commission on Human Rights (DCWP FAQ VII).
Does Local Law 144 apply to the vendor or the employer?
It applies to the employer or employment agency. A vendor may commission an audit but is not responsible for one (DCWP FAQ V.1 to V.2).
What must a Local Law 144 audit summary include?
It must include the audit date, the data source and explanation, the unknown-category count, the number of applicants, and rates and impact ratios for all categories (6 RCNY § 5-303). The full list is in the publication section above.
How long must a bias audit summary stay posted?
It must stay posted for at least six months after the latest use of the tool (6 RCNY § 5-303).
How often must the audit be repeated?
The audit must be no more than one year old when the tool is used (Admin. Code §§ 20-870 to 20-874).
Can an employer use a vendor's audit?
Sometimes. Under 6 RCNY § 5-302, an employer may rely on an audit that uses other employers' historical data only if it provided its own historical data to the auditor or has never used the tool, and test data is allowed if historical data is insufficient. A vendor may commission an audit, but the employer is ultimately responsible for it (DCWP FAQ V.1 to V.2). How a bias audit is conducted covers the data rules.
Is a scored AI interview covered?
That is a scope question for counsel under the "substantially assist or replace discretionary decision-making" test, and this page does not answer it.
See a ZeaHire evidence pack in a demo: per-question evidence behind each score for one candidate. Whether your use falls inside Local Law 144 is a question for your counsel.
Comments
No comments yet — start the conversation.