New — The State of AI Hiring 2026. Every number sourced→
AI & Technology

AI Hiring Compliance Questions for Vendors: A Law-by-Law List

AI hiring compliance questions to ask any vendor, law by law: NYC, Illinois, Colorado, California, EU, UK, plus documents to request. Copy into your RFP.

Compliance questions for vendors. 33 questions, law by law, and the documents to ask for before you sign.

TL;DR: Ask every AI hiring vendor what its tool does, where a person decides, what candidates are told, what testing exists, what it keeps and which documents it will hand over. Then add the questions for each law that reaches your roles.

Updated 18 November 2026. A buyer's question list, not legal advice.

When you need this

You are shortlisting or renewing a vendor for AI that screens, scores or interviews candidates. This is part of the AI interviewer RFP template.

How to use this list

  1. Start with the cross-law questions. They apply wherever your candidates live.
  2. Pick the tables that match where your roles and candidates are.
  3. Ask for written answers and the document behind each.
  4. Laws change; every law fact below is dated. Check the current text, and check with your legal adviser about what applies to you.

Questions every buyer should ask any vendor

Before any single law comes into play, these eight questions do most of the work. They hold wherever your candidates live, because most of the rules below turn on the same few facts: what the tool does, whether a person decides, what candidates are told, and what evidence exists. In practice you own the hiring decision and what candidates see, while the vendor owns the product, its testing and its documentation. Listen for specifics. A strong answer names a person, a date and a document you can have in writing. A vague answer, or "it depends on the customer," usually means the work has not been done.

QuestionWhy it mattersA strong answer includes
What does the tool do, and which decisions does it influence?Several rules turn on how much the tool influences a decision.A plain list of inputs, outputs and where the output is used.
Where does a person review or override a result?Several laws ask for human review.Who reviews, what they see, how overrides are logged.
What are candidates told, and how is consent captured?Rules differ by place.Exact candidate text, timestamped consent, a way to opt out.
What bias testing or impact data exists?You may need it for audits and defenses.Method, date, who ran it, and results by group.
What do you keep, for how long, and who can delete it?Retention and deletion duties vary.Default periods, per-customer settings, deletion proof.
Can you explain a score for one candidate?Some laws require explanations.Evidence per question, in plain language, exportable.
How do candidates request an accommodation?Disability law applies to tests and interviews.A non-AI path, logged requests, no penalty.
What are your duties as a developer?Developers can carry their own duties.Documentation and change log.

New York City: Local Law 144

Who it covers: the city's DCWP page says the law bars employers and employment agencies from using an automated employment decision tool unless it has had a bias audit within one year of use, audit information is public and the required notices were given. DCWP began enforcement on 5 July 2023 and says notice is due 10 business days before use (read 18 Nov 2026). The NYS Comptroller published an enforcement audit on 2 December 2025 (OSC, read 18 Nov 2026). See our NYC guide. Check the current text.

For a staffing owner, notice who the DCWP wording points at: employers and employment agencies. The DCWP page also says complaints can be filed against an employment agency (read 18 Nov 2026), so an agency placing people into New York City roles should not assume the tool's maker carries the audit. The vendor usually holds the raw material an audit needs, such as test data and the counts behind it. As DCWP describes it, the bar is on whoever uses the tool, so check that an audit exists, that its summary is public and that candidates get notice. Listen for a named independent auditor, a date, and a clear yes on publishing the summary. "Our customers handle that" is a weak answer.

QuestionWhy it mattersA strong answer includes
Is there an independent bias audit, and when?DCWP says the audit must be within one year before use (read 18 Nov 2026).Auditor, date, independence statement.
Can we publish the audit summary?DCWP says audit information must be public (read 18 Nov 2026).Written permission and the summary format.
What notice text and retention statement can we use?DCWP says notice comes 10 business days before use; our guide describes a retention policy on request (read 18 Nov 2026).Ready templates and accommodation wording.

Illinois: HB 3773 and the AI Video Interview Act

Who it covers: per our Illinois guide, HB 3773 covers employers' use of AI in employment decisions, reported effective 1 January 2026; the Video Interview Act covers AI analysis of video interviews for Illinois-based positions, effective 1 January 2020 (read 18 Nov 2026). Burke Law and Seyfarth report the proposed rules were withdrawn 2 June 2026 (read 18 Nov 2026).

Both Illinois rules, as our Illinois guide describes them, are written around the employer. HB 3773 asks employers to tell applicants and employees when AI is used and bars zip code as a stand-in for protected traits. The Video Interview Act asks for notice, an explanation of how the AI works and consent before the interview, plus deletion on request. The vendor's role is to make those steps possible: a plain list of what it evaluates, a stored consent record, and deletion that reaches copies held by others. Listen for a vendor that can name the characteristics and show its deletion process, rather than only promise one.

QuestionWhy it mattersA strong answer includes
Which characteristics does the AI evaluate in a video?Our guide says the Act requires an explanation before the interview.A plain list, shown to candidates.
How is notice given and consent recorded?Notice and consent come before the interview.Script, timestamp, stored consent record.
Can you delete one applicant's video within 30 days, including copies?Our guide describes a 30-day deletion duty.Process covering sub-processors, with proof.
What notice of AI use can we give applicants and employees, and does any feature use zip code?Our guide says HB 3773 requires notice and bars zip code as a proxy (read 18 Nov 2026).Notice text and a list of inputs.

Colorado: SB 26-189

Who it covers: developers and deployers of automated decision-making technology that materially influences a consequential decision, including hiring. SB 26-189 was signed 14 May 2026, and developer documentation starts 1 January 2027 (Colorado General Assembly, read 18 Nov 2026). Check the deployer start date. See our Colorado guide.

Colorado is the clearest case of duties split between two parties. The bill page says developer documentation starts 1 January 2027 (read 18 Nov 2026), so ask now what documentation the vendor will hand over, and when. On the employer side, our guide, citing Littler and Ogletree, describes a pre-use notice, a plain-language explanation within 30 days of an adverse outcome, and human review "to the extent commercially reasonable." You cannot meet an explanation deadline without the vendor's records, so test whether it can produce per-candidate evidence and a transcript quickly. Listen for a sample of the documentation and a change log, not a promise that one is coming.

QuestionWhy it mattersA strong answer includes
What technical documentation do you give deployers?Developer documentation starts 1 January 2027 (read 18 Nov 2026).A sample and a delivery date.
Can you support a plain-language explanation of an adverse outcome?Littler and Ogletree report a 30-day explanation duty for employers, as summarized on our page (read 18 Nov 2026).Per-question evidence and transcript export.
How does a candidate ask for human review or reconsideration?Our guide says review "to the extent commercially reasonable" (read 18 Nov 2026).A documented route and who handles it.
Do you keep version identifiers and change logs for three years, and tell us about material updates?Our guide lists these as developer duties (read 18 Nov 2026).Sample change log and notice process.
What pre-use notice text do you supply?Our guide describes a clear pre-use notice (read 18 Nov 2026).Ready text with a link for more information.

California: Civil Rights Council rules and CCPA

Who it covers: Mayer Brown reports that the Civil Rights Council's automated-decision rules took effect 1 October 2025 and extend liability to agents acting for an employer, with four-year record retention (Mayer Brown, read 18 Nov 2026). Paul Hastings and Thompson Coburn report CCPA automated-decision (ADMT) rules, with compliance for significant decisions from 1 January 2027 (read 18 Nov 2026). See our California guide.

California has two layers, and they land differently. Under the Civil Rights Council rules the records sit in the vendor's system while the exposure can reach you. The CCPA rules add notice, access and opt-out questions from 1 January 2027 for significant decisions. So ask two things: can the vendor give you the full record period, and can it support those requests? Listen for per-candidate exports, a dated testing record and clear indemnity wording. Mayer Brown reports testing is relevant evidence in a defense, so ask for one.

QuestionWhy it mattersA strong answer includes
Can you give us four years of inputs, outputs and criteria?Reported four-year retention (read 18 Nov 2026).Export per candidate, kept through contract end.
How do you handle notice, access and opt-out requests?Reported CCPA duties from 2027.Notice text, request workflow, documented exceptions.
What anti-bias testing have you done, and how recent is it?Mayer Brown reports testing is relevant evidence in a defense (read 18 Nov 2026).Method, date and results.
Will you cooperate with a records request, and what are your indemnity terms?Agents can carry liability, per Mayer Brown (read 18 Nov 2026).Cooperation commitment and indemnity wording.

EU AI Act

Who it covers: per our EU guide, recruitment and candidate-evaluation AI is a high-risk category, and the Act reaches systems whose output is used in the EU (read 18 Nov 2026). White & Case and Hunton report that Regulation (EU) 2026/1744 moved those duties to 2 December 2027. We did not read the official text, so check the current text.

Our EU guide treats recruitment AI as a high-risk category with duties on both sides. The vendor, as provider, supplies instructions for use and the documentation behind the system. You, as deployer, use the tool as instructed, assign human oversight and keep logs, which our guide puts at six months. You are buying for a future date, but you can ask now whether the vendor already works to that standard. Listen for oversight controls described in practice, logs you can export, and a clear no on inferring emotion from face or voice, since our guide says that has been prohibited at work since 2 February 2025.

QuestionWhy it mattersA strong answer includes
Do you supply instructions for use and oversight design?Employers use the system per those instructions.Documentation and oversight controls.
What logs exist, how long are they kept, can we export them?Our guide describes a six-month log duty for deployers.Log fields, retention, export.
Does the product infer emotion from face or voice?Our EU guide says emotion inference at work has been prohibited since 2 February 2025 (read 18 Nov 2026).A clear no, or exactly what is analyzed.
Where is candidate data stored and processed?Location drives which transfer rules apply.Regions, sub-processors and transfer terms.

EU and UK GDPR: automated decisions

Who it covers: in the EU, Article 22 gives a right not to be subject to decisions based solely on automated processing that have legal or similarly significant effects, subject to exceptions and safeguards (GDPR Art. 22, read 18 Nov 2026). In the UK, law firms report that the Data (Use and Access) Act 2025 replaced Article 22 with new Articles 22A to 22D, and the ICO published draft guidance on 31 March 2026. Check the current UK text. See also AI note takers and GDPR.

Article 22 is about whether a decision is made solely by automated means. That depends on how you use the tool, so ask for a decision map showing where a person decides. Article 28 is about the contract: it sets what a written agreement between a controller and a processor covers, including instructions, sub-processors, deletion or return of data and audits. If the vendor is your processor, that agreement is where its duties live. Listen for a signed DPA, a sub-processor list and a human step that can actually change the outcome. UK rules are in flux, so ask which version the vendor works to.

QuestionWhy it mattersA strong answer includes
Is any outcome solely automated, or does a person decide?The answer sets which rules apply.A decision map showing the human step.
Can a candidate challenge a result and reach a person?Safeguards include human intervention.A documented route.
Does your DPA cover instructions, sub-processors, deletion and audits?Article 28 sets what a processor contract covers (GDPR Art. 28, read 18 Nov 2026).A signed DPA and a sub-processor list.

Other states

Who it covers: a patchwork; use our state tracker. New Jersey disparate-impact rules were reported in force from 15 December 2025 (Morgan Lewis, as cited on our tracker, read 18 Nov 2026). Maryland restricts facial recognition in interviews unless the applicant consents by signed waiver (HB 1202, read 18 Nov 2026).

Outside the laws above, the picture is a patchwork, and your first job is knowing where your candidates sit. Duties usually fall on the employer, so the vendor's role is to tell you which state laws its design accounts for and when it last checked. Maryland is a useful test for interview tools: ask for a plain yes or no on face analysis. Listen for a named list of states with a review date, and a plain yes or no on face analysis. A vendor that says it covers "all states" without a list has probably not looked.

QuestionWhy it mattersA strong answer includes
Which state laws does your design account for?Candidates may sit in several states.A named list, with a review date.
Does any feature use face analysis?Some states require consent.A yes or no, and the consent step.

Documents to ask for

  • Bias audit summary: see what a bias audit is.
  • Impact ratios: see the four-fifths rule.
  • Notice and consent templates.
  • A data processing agreement (DPA), with sub-processors.
  • Record-retention policy.
  • Model or feature change log.

What the lawsuits tell buyers

In Mobley v. Workday (N.D. Cal.), the court on 12 July 2024 allowed a claim that the vendor acted as the employers' agent to proceed. That claim survived a motion; it is not a finding. An age-discrimination collective received preliminary certification on 16 May 2025, a first-stage step, and a motion for broader class certification was reported filed in September 2026 (all reported; read 18 Nov 2026). Check the docket.

Federal AI guidance was removed from the EEOC site in early 2025 (K&L Gates, 31 Jan 2025, read 18 Nov 2026), but Title VII, the ADEA and the ADA still apply, per Cooley (read 18 Nov 2026). More cases are in our lawsuit tracker, and recording rules are in interview recording consent.

How ZeaHire answers these

ZeaHire is our product. Ask us for ZeaHire's answers to this list in your demo.

  • Recruiters approve, reject, move stage and submit to the client. Nothing goes to a client on its own.
  • Every candidate on a job gets the same template questions, and each answer is scored against what a strong answer covers, with written reasoning.
  • ZeaHire connects with nearly a dozen ATS and HR systems, including Workday, SAP SuccessFactors, Greenhouse, JazzHR and JobDiva. If yours isn't on the list, we'll build the connection. Ask to see it with your own system in a demo.

FAQ

What is hiring compliance?

Following the laws on how you recruit and select people: anti-discrimination, privacy, notice and record-keeping. With AI, it also covers testing and explanations.

Can artificial intelligence make the hiring process more fair?

It depends on the tool, its data and how people use it. Consistent questions can reduce variation, but a tool can also reproduce bias. Ask for testing evidence and see explainable AI in hiring.

Should companies have an AI policy?

Many do. A policy can state which tools are approved, where a person decides, what candidates are told and who owns vendor review.

Should companies use AI to assess job candidates?

That is your call; some laws attach notice, testing or review duties. Compare vendors with which AI recruiting platform to buy and how AI interviews work.

What should be in an AI recruiting vendor's due diligence?

The tool's function, human review, notice, bias testing, retention, explanations, accommodations and the documents above.

Back to the RFP template hub; also the AI interviewer security questionnaire, best AI interview software and the staffing agency RFP.

Take this list into a demo

Book a demo

AI interviewsBuying guides
Was this useful?

Comments

No comments yet — start the conversation.

Leave a comment

Your email is never published. Comments appear once a moderator approves them.

Replying to
Plain text only. Be kind and stay on topic.

By commenting you agree to our privacy policy.